Acciones

Relación 5

De Razonamiento automático (2018-19)

chapter {* R5: Recorridos de árboles *}

theory R5_Recorridos_de_arboles_alu
imports Main 
begin 

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 1. Definir el tipo de datos arbol para representar los
  árboles binarios que tiene información en los nodos y en las hojas. 
  Por ejemplo, el árbol
          e
         / \
        /   \
       c     g
      / \   / \
     a   d f   h 
  se representa por "N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h))".
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

datatype 'a arbol = H "'a" | N "'a" "'a arbol" "'a arbol"

value "N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h))" 

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 2. Definir la función 
     preOrden :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a list"
  tal que (preOrden a) es el recorrido pre orden del árbol a. Por
  ejemplo, 
     preOrden (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h)))
     = [e,c,a,d,g,f,h] 
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim raffergon2 aribatval benber josgomrom4 hugrubsan
   cammonagu antramhur alfmarcua enrparalv marfruman1 gleherlop
   chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue alikan juacanrod *)  
fun preOrden :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a list" where
  "preOrden (H x)     = [x]" |
  "preOrden (N x i d) = x # preOrden i @ preOrden d"

value "preOrden (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h)))  
      = [e,c,a,d,g,f,h]" 

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 3. Definir la función 
     postOrden :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a list"
  tal que (postOrden a) es el recorrido post orden del árbol a. Por
  ejemplo, 
     postOrden (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h)))
     = [e,c,a,d,g,f,h] 
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim raffergon2 aribatval benber josgomrom4 hugrubsan
   cammonagu antramhur alfmarcua enrparalv marfruman1 gleherlop
   chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue alikan juacanrod *)  
fun postOrden :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a list" where
  "postOrden (H x)     = [x]" |
  "postOrden (N x i d) = postOrden i @ postOrden d @ [x]"

value "postOrden (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h)))
       = [a,d,c,f,h,g,e]"

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 4. Definir la función 
     inOrden :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a list"
  tal que (inOrden a) es el recorrido in orden del árbol a. Por
  ejemplo, 
     inOrden (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h)))
     = [a,c,d,e,f,g,h]
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim raffergon2 aribatval benber josgomrom4 hugrubsan
   gleherlop cammonagu alfmarcua enrparalv marfruman1 chrgencar giafus1
   pabbergue alikan juacanrod antramhur *)  
fun inOrden :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a list" where
  "inOrden (H x)     = [x]" |
  "inOrden (N x i d) = inOrden i @ [x] @ inOrden d"

value "inOrden (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h)))
       = [a,c,d,e,f,g,h]"

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 5. Definir la función 
     espejo :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a arbol"
  tal que (espejo a) es la imagen especular del árbol a. Por ejemplo, 
     espejo (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h)))
     = N e (N g (H h) (H f)) (N c (H d) (H a))
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim raffergon2 aribatval benber josgomrom4 hugrubsan
   gleherlop cammonagu alfmarcua enrparalv marfruman1 chrgencar giafus1
   pabbergue alikan juacanrod antramhur *)  
fun espejo :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a arbol" where
  "espejo (H x)     = H x" |
  "espejo (N x i d) = N x (espejo d) (espejo i)"

value "espejo (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h))) 
       = N e (N g (H h) (H f)) (N c (H d) (H a))"

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 6. Demostrar que
     preOrden (espejo a) = rev (postOrden a)
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim raffergon2 josgomrom4 hugrubsan cammonagu
   alfmarcua gleherlop enrparalv marfruman1 chrgencar pabbergue giafus1
  alikan juacanrod aribatval antramhur *) 
lemma  "preOrden (espejo a) = rev (postOrden a)" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x i d
  assume H1: "?P i"
  assume H2: "?P d"
  have "preOrden (espejo (N x i d)) = 
        preOrden (N x (espejo d) (espejo i))" by simp
  also have "... = x # preOrden (espejo d) @ preOrden (espejo i)" 
    by simp
  also have "... = x # rev (postOrden d) @ rev (postOrden i)"
    using H1 H2 by simp
  also have "... = rev (postOrden d @ [x]) @ rev (postOrden i)" by simp
  also have "... = rev (postOrden i @ postOrden d @ [x])" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
qed

(* benber *)
lemma  "preOrden (espejo a) = rev (postOrden a)"
proof (induction a)
  case (H v)
  show ?case by simp
next
  case IS: (N v l r)
  have "preOrden (espejo (N v l r)) = 
        preOrden (N v (espejo r) (espejo l))" by simp
  also have "... = v # (preOrden (espejo r)) @ (preOrden (espejo l))" 
    by simp
  also have "... = v # rev (postOrden r) @ rev (postOrden l)" 
    using IS.IH by simp
  also have "... = rev ((postOrden l) @ (postOrden r) @ [v])" by simp
  also have "... = rev (postOrden (N v l r))" by simp
  finally show ?case .
qed

(* cammonagu *)
lemma "preOrden (espejo a) = rev (postOrden a)"
  by (induction a) auto

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 7. Demostrar que
     postOrden (espejo a) = rev (preOrden a)
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim josgomrom4 hugrubsan cammonagu enrparalv
   gleherlop chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue alikan aribatval *) 
lemma "postOrden (espejo a) = rev (preOrden a)" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x i d
  assume H1: "?P i" and H2: "?P d"
  have "postOrden (espejo (N x i d)) =
        postOrden (N x (espejo d) (espejo i))" by simp
  also have "... = postOrden (espejo d) @ postOrden (espejo i) @ [x]"
    by simp
  also have "... = rev (preOrden d) @ rev (preOrden i) @ [x]"
    using H1 H2 by simp
  also have "... = rev (preOrden i @ preOrden d) @ rev [x]" by simp
  also have "... = rev (x # preOrden i @ preOrden d)" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
qed

(* raffergon2 alfmarcua marfruman1 juacanrod antramhur *)
lemma "postOrden (espejo a) = rev (preOrden a)" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x i d 
  assume H1: "?P i"
  assume H2: "?P d"
  have "postOrden (espejo (N x i d)) = 
        postOrden (N x (espejo d) (espejo i))" by simp
  also have "... = postOrden (espejo d) @ postOrden (espejo i) @ [x]"
    by simp
  also have "... = rev(preOrden d) @ rev (preOrden i) @ [x]"
    using H1 H2 by simp
  also have "... = rev(preOrden d) @ rev (x # preOrden i)" by simp
  also have "... = rev(x # preOrden i @ preOrden d)" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
qed

(* benber cammonagu *)
lemma "postOrden (espejo a) = rev (preOrden a)"
  by (induction a) auto

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 8. Demostrar que
     inOrden (espejo a) = rev (inOrden a)
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim josgomrom4 hugrubsan cammonagu enrparalv
   gleherlop chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue alikan juacanrod aribatval *) 
theorem "inOrden (espejo a) = rev (inOrden a)" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x i d
  assume H1: "?P i" and H2: "?P d"
  have "inOrden (espejo (N x i d)) = 
        inOrden (N x (espejo d) (espejo i))"
    by simp
  also have "... = inOrden (espejo d) @ [x] @ inOrden (espejo i)" 
    by simp
  also have "... = rev (inOrden d) @ [x] @ rev (inOrden i)"
    using H1 H2 by simp
  also have "... = rev (inOrden i @ [x] @ inOrden d)" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
qed

(* raffergon2 alfmarcua marfruman1 antramhur *)
theorem "inOrden (espejo a) = rev (inOrden a)" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a) 
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x i d
  assume H1: "?P i"
  assume H2: "?P d"
  have "inOrden (espejo (N x i d)) = inOrden(N x (espejo d) (espejo i))" 
    by simp
  also have "... = inOrden (espejo d) @ [x] @ inOrden (espejo i)" 
    by simp
  also have "... = rev (inOrden d) @ [x] @ rev (inOrden i)"
    using H1 H2 by simp
  also have "... = rev(x # inOrden d) @ rev (inOrden i)" by simp
  also have "... = rev(inOrden i @ x # inOrden d)" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
qed

(* benber *)
theorem "inOrden (espejo a) = rev (inOrden a)"
proof (induction a)
  case (H v)
  show ?case by simp
next
  case IS: (N v l r)
  have "inOrden (espejo (N v l r)) = 
        inOrden (N v (espejo r) (espejo l))" by simp
  also have "... = (inOrden (espejo r)) @ [v] @ (inOrden (espejo l))" 
    by simp
  also have "... = (rev (inOrden r)) @ [v] @ (rev (inOrden l))" 
    using IS.IH by simp
  also have "... = rev ((inOrden l) @ [v] @ (inOrden r))" by simp
  also have"... = rev (inOrden (N v l r))" by simp
  finally show ?case .
qed

(* cammonagu*)
lemma "inOrden (espejo a) = rev (inOrden a)"
  by (induction a) auto

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 9. Definir la función 
     raiz :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a"
  tal que (raiz a) es la raiz del árbol a. Por ejemplo, 
     raiz (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h))) = e
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim raffergon2 aribatval benber josgomrom4 hugrubsan
   cammonagu antramhur alfmarcua enrparalv marfruman1 gleherlop
   chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue alikan juacanrod *)  
fun raiz :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a" where
  "raiz (H x)     = x" |
  "raiz (N x i d) = x"

value "raiz (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h))) = e"

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 10. Definir la función 
     extremo_izquierda :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a"
  tal que (extremo_izquierda a) es el nodo más a la izquierda del árbol
  a. Por ejemplo,  
     extremo_izquierda (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h))) = a
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim raffergon2 benber josgomrom4 gleherlop hugrubsan
   cammonagu alfmarcua enrparalv marfruman1 chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue
   alikan juacanrod aribatval antramhur *) 
fun extremo_izquierda :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a" where
  "extremo_izquierda (H x)     = x" |
  "extremo_izquierda (N x i d) = extremo_izquierda i"

value "extremo_izquierda (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h))) = a"

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 11. Definir la función 
     extremo_derecha :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a"
  tal que (extremo_derecha a) es el nodo más a la derecha del árbol
  a. Por ejemplo,  
     extremo_derecha (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h))) = h
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim raffergon2 benber josgomrom4 hugrubsan cammonagu
   alfmarcua gleherlop enrparalv marfruman1 chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue
   alikan juacanrod antramhur *) 
fun extremo_derecha :: "'a arbol ⇒ 'a" where
  "extremo_derecha (H x)     = x" |
  "extremo_derecha (N x i d) = extremo_derecha d"

value "extremo_derecha (N e (N c (H a) (H d)) (N g (H f) (H h))) = h"

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 12. Demostrar o refutar
     last (inOrden a) = extremo_derecha a
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim josgomrom4 hugrubsan cammonagu alfmarcua
   enrparalv gleherlop chrgencar marfruman1 giafus1 pabbergue alikan
   juacanrod antramhur *)  
lemma inOrdenNotNil: "inOrden a ≠ []" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x i d
  have "?P (N x i d) = ((inOrden i @ [x] @ inOrden d) ≠ [])" by simp
  also have "... = ((inOrden i ≠ []) ∨ ([x] ≠ []) ∨ (inOrden d ≠ []))" 
    by simp
  also have "... = ([x] ≠ [])" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
qed

theorem "last (inOrden a) = extremo_derecha a" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x i d
  assume HI: "?P d"
  have "last (inOrden (N x i d)) = last (inOrden i @ [x] @ inOrden d)" 
    by simp
  also have "... = last (x # inOrden d)" by simp
  also have "... = last (inOrden d)" by (simp add: inOrdenNotNil)
  also have "... = extremo_derecha d" using HI by simp
  also have "... = extremo_derecha (N x i d)" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" .
qed

(* benber *)
theorem "last (inOrden a) = extremo_derecha a"
proof (induction a)
  case (H v)
  show ?case by simp
next
  case IS: (N v l r)
  have 1: "last (xs@ys) = last ys" if "ys ≠ []" for xs ys :: "'a list"
  proof (induction xs)
    case Nil
    show ?case by simp
  next
    case IS: (Cons x xs)
    have "last ((x#xs)@ys) = last (x#(xs@ys))" by simp
    also have "... = last (xs @ ys)" using `ys ≠ []` by simp
    also have "... = last ys" using IS.IH by simp
    finally show ?case .
  qed
  have 2: "inOrden a ≠ []" for a :: "'a arbol"
    by (induction a) auto
  have "last (inOrden (N v l r)) = 
        last ( (inOrden l) @ [v] @ (inOrden r) )" by simp
  also have "... = last (inOrden r)" using 1 2 by auto
  also have "... = extremo_derecha r" using IS.IH by simp
  also have "... = extremo_derecha (N v l r)" by simp
  finally show ?case .
qed

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 13. Demostrar o refutar
     hd (inOrden a) = extremo_izquierda a
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim josgomrom4 hugrubsan cammonagu alfmarcua
   gleherlop enrparalv marfruman1 chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue alikan
   juacanrod aribatval antramhur *) 
theorem "hd (inOrden a) = extremo_izquierda a" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x::'a
  have "hd (inOrden (H x)) = hd [x]" by simp
  also have "... = x" by simp
  also have "... = extremo_izquierda (H x)" by simp
  finally show "?P (H x)" .
next
  fix x i d
  assume HI: "?P i"
  have "hd (inOrden (N x i d)) = hd (inOrden i @ [x] @ inOrden d)" 
    by simp
  also have "... = hd ((inOrden i @ [x]) @ inOrden d)" by simp
  also have "... = hd (inOrden i)" by (simp add: inOrdenNotNil)
  also have "... = extremo_izquierda i" using HI by simp
  also have "... = extremo_izquierda (N x i d)" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" .
qed

(* benber *)
theorem "hd (inOrden a) = extremo_izquierda a"
proof (induction a)
  case (H v)
  show ?case by simp
next
  case IS: (N v l r)
  moreover have "inOrden a ≠ []" for a :: "'a arbol"
    by (induction a) auto
  ultimately show ?case by simp
qed

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 14. Demostrar o refutar
     hd (preOrden a) = last (postOrden a)
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim josgomrom4 hugrubsan cammonagu alfmarcua
   gleherlop marfruman1 chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue alikan juacanrod
   aribatval antramhur *)  
theorem hdPreOrden_lastPostOrden: 
  "hd (preOrden a) = last (postOrden a)" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x::'a 
  fix i d
  have "hd (preOrden (N x i d)) = hd (x # preOrden i @ preOrden d)" 
    by simp
  also have "... = x" by simp
  also have "... = last [x]" by simp
  also have "... = last (postOrden i @ postOrden d @ [x])" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
qed

(* enrparalv *)
theorem "hd (preOrden a) = last (postOrden a)" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x::'a
  have "hd (preOrden (H x)) = hd [x]" by simp
  also have "... = x" by simp
  also have "... = last [x]" by simp
  also have "... = last (postOrden (H x))" by simp
  finally show "?P (H x)" by simp 
next
  fix x i d
  have "hd (preOrden (N x i d)) = hd ([x] @ preOrden i @ preOrden d)" 
    by simp
  also have "... = hd ([x] @ preOrden i)" by simp
  also have "... = x" by simp
  also have "... = last [x] " by simp
  also have "... = last (postOrden i @ postOrden d @ [x]) " by simp
  also have "... = last (postOrden (N x i d))" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
oops

(* benber cammonagu *)
theorem "hd (preOrden a) = last (postOrden a)"
  by (cases a) auto

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 15. Demostrar o refutar
     hd (preOrden a) = raiz a
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim josgomrom4 hugrubsan cammonagu alfmarcua
   gleherlop marfruman1 chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue alikan juacanrod
   aribatval antramhur *) 
theorem hdPreOrden_raiz: "hd (preOrden a) = raiz a" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x::'a
  fix i d
  have "hd (preOrden (N x i d)) = hd (x # preOrden i @ preOrden d)" 
    by simp
  also have "... = x" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by (simp only: raiz.simps(2))
qed

(* enrparalv *)
theorem "hd (preOrden a) = raiz a" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x::'a
  have "hd (preOrden (H x)) = hd [x]" by simp
  also have "... = x " by simp
  also have "... = raiz (H x)" by (simp only: raiz.simps(1))
  finally show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x i d
  have "hd (preOrden (N x i d)) = hd ([x] @ preOrden i @ preOrden d)" by simp
  also have "... = hd (([x] @ preOrden i) @ preOrden d)" by simp
  also have "... = hd ([x] @ preOrden i)" by simp
  also have "... = hd ([x])" by simp
  also have "... = x" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by (simp only: raiz.simps(2))
oops

(* benber cammonagu*)
theorem "hd (preOrden a) = raiz a"
  by (cases a) auto

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 16. Demostrar o refutar
     hd (inOrden a) = raiz a
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim cammonagu alfmarcua marfruman1 gleherlop
   chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue juacanrod hugrubsan alikan aribatval
   antramhur *) 
theorem "hd (inOrden a) = raiz a"
  quickcheck
(*
Quickcheck found a counterexample:
  a = N a⇩1 (H a⇩2) (H a⇩1)
Evaluated terms:
  hd (inOrden a) = a⇩2
  raiz a = a⇩1 *)
  oops

(* benber josgomrom4 *)
(* El teorema no es cierto para arboles sobre numeros naturales *)
theorem "¬(∀ a :: nat arbol. hd (inOrden a) = raiz a)"
proof -
  let ?a = "(N 0 (H 1) (H 2)) :: nat arbol"
  have "hd (inOrden ?a) = 1" by simp
  moreover have "raiz ?a = 0" by simp
  ultimately have "hd (inOrden ?a) ≠ raiz ?a" by simp
  hence "∃ a :: nat arbol. hd (inOrden a) ≠ raiz a" by (simp only: exI)
  thus ?thesis by auto
qed

text {*  
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
  Ejercicio 17. Demostrar o refutar
     last (postOrden a) = raiz a
  --------------------------------------------------------------------- 
*}

(* pabalagon manperjim josgomrom4 cammonagu marfruman1 gleherlop
   chrgencar giafus1 pabbergue juacanrod hugrubsan aribatval antramhur *) 
theorem "last (postOrden a) = raiz a"
proof -
  have "last (postOrden a) = hd (preOrden a)"
    by (simp add: hdPreOrden_lastPostOrden)
  also have "... = raiz a" by (simp add: hdPreOrden_raiz)
  finally show "?thesis" .
qed

(* benber cammonagu*)
theorem "last (postOrden a) = raiz a"
  by (cases a) auto

(* alfmarcua *)
theorem "last (postOrden a) = raiz a" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x
  show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x::'a
  fix i d
  have "last (postOrden (N x i d)) = 
        last (postOrden i @ postOrden d @ [x])" by simp
  also have "... = x" by simp
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
qed

(* enrparalv *)
theorem "last (postOrden a) = raiz a" (is "?P a")
proof (induct a)
  fix x::'a
  have "last (postOrden (H x)) = last [x]" by simp
  also have "... = x" by simp
  also have "... = raiz (H x)" by (simp only: raiz.simps(1))
  finally show "?P (H x)" by simp
next
  fix x i d
  have "last (postOrden (N x i d)) = 
        last (postOrden i @ postOrden d @ [x])" by simp
  also have "... = x" by simp
  also have "... = raiz (N x i d)" by (simp only: raiz.simps(2))
  finally show "?P (N x i d)" by simp
oops

end